Monday, December 22, 2008

Senate Posts

Relevant Link

Well, finally Stephen Harper has given an early Christmas present to 18 people for the plush job of the Senate.  Long since Preston Manning held a fiesta for a senator long removed from Canada, Harper managed to fill the senate with a bunch of quiet-spoken backbenchers and backroom strategists who will most likely do as they are told.  The exceptions, of course, are former journalists Pamela Wallen and Mike Duffy.  I personally think the Duff is a great choice for the senate and probably knows more about the government of Canada than anyone.  How appropriate it is for a journalist to become a politician is up in the air.  Other than that, I think it is pretty telling how half of the appointments don't even have pages on Wikipedia.  Many commentators are wondering about the lack of Reformers on the list, such as Preston Manning, without realizing that Alberta had no vacancies.  A big WTF is the appointment of Nancy Greene Raine, but I suppose it is no worse than the appointment of former Leaf Frank Mahovlich.

Another thing most commentators don't realize is that Harper's vain attempts to reform the senate are futile and unconstitutional.  The only way senate reform will happen is if the provinces finally get their acts together and agree on a method to do it.  As of right now, Alberta and Saskatchewan are the only provinces pushing for senate elections, and I find it highly unlikely that at least one of Ontario or Quebec will go for it either.  Without one of the two most populous provinces, senate reform will not happen, as it requires reopening the constitution.  Of course, Harper could bring about a national referendum on this, but I doubt most people care that much.

One stipulation is that the senate terms are for 8 years, but I somehow doubt that it is binding.  Who wants to bet these senators will find it rather comfortable, and when the eight years are up and after failed attempts to make elections that they just stay there?  They are entitled to their entitlements, so they say.

Relevant Link

Perhaps of more concern is the low radar appointment of a federal judge.  By the article, it sounds like Thomas Cromwell is an agreeable choice, however it flies in the face of the vetting process that Harper himself set up at the start of his first term in government.

The Governor General should really look into how constitutional all of these appointments are.  Appointments during non-confidence times just doesn't seem right.  Although I fully agree that the senate is overly stacked with Liberals, I still don't see it as an excuse to ignore the wide variety of political opinions in this country.  A Stephen Harper of the opposition 6 years ago would have agreed.

No comments: